• 2 Posts
  • 269 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle













  • Damn, dude, not every hunter is a deer population manager.

    Hunters do hunting, surgeons try and heal people. In one the killing is the point and in the other the cutting in incidental.

    Avoiding factory farmed animals but still eating animals is something a lot of people say to pat themselves on the back, but I don’t buy it.

    Anyway, I can see this is a really personal thing to you and you’re really upset by it. Don’t think too much about why you get defensive about it, though, or why you have to carve out exceptions to try and make it less creepy.



  • Since you mentioned eating

    No, I specifically tried to avoid it, but go ahead and ignore that 🤦

    Hiking is a thing you can do in nature alone or is groups that doesn’t involve killing, so I don’t understand your point about that making hunting less creepy. And even if most of the hobby isn’t the actual killing, the rest of it is planning, setting up for, fantasizing about, talking about, etc., the killing, so that’s not very convincing either. Like I get that if you have, say, cooking as a hobby that you look up recipes, buy ingredients, and eat, but nobody that has cooking as a hobby buys ingredients to not cook (raw vegans excepted 🥁🥁🛎️).

    And telling me about how different flesh tastes depending on how you kill them sounds pretty creepy.





    • you kill insects so you’re just as bad
    • But I eat it so it’s ethical and respectful (nothing to do with the opinion I expressed)
    • Cats are different than game
    • Population control (nothing to do with the opinion I expressed)

    I’m pushing away the arguments because they don’t actually address my point. They’re bad rhetoric. THEY are not giving valid reasons, it’s the same stuff I’ve heard before and it’s still bad rhetoric, that’s why I’m pushing them away. Pick one and we can go through it if you want.